
Just because it’s a legal holiday, doesn’t mean that I have to celebrate it.
Today I took a yoga class with a teacher I’d never learned from before. She told us that the theme of our class would be “exploration,” in honor of Christopher Columbus. That was a weird moment for me, in the middle of a room where I seemed to be one of few… actually, I might have been the only “non-white” person.
I thought about leaving right then and there. I figured that I’d already been offended, was pretty sure that I would have a tough time concentrating on yoga, and the heated room was not going to help me cool down.
For years, I was self-taught in yoga. I was serious but avoided classes because I thought it might have too many awkward moments. I may be only quasi-Indian (half black American and raised with little or no Indian culture) but it’s still weird to be in a room full of white people chanting in Sanskrit… or having a Western yoga teacher know more than me.
I got over it, and started taking classes – for the most part, really enjoying them and improving my practice. I would have even enjoyed today’s class for the poses themselves, but not for the commentary on Christopher Columbus. The class was well beyond awkward; it was infuriating to the point of rage. I was practicing enraged yoga, which was paradoxical but motivating. My poses were deeper than usual. I imagined each of them as a big middle finger to the teacher.
You see, Christopher Columbus, was an explorer widely credited with helping Europe find and conquer the Americas. How you feel about him has everything to do with whether you identify more with the aggressors or the people who resisted the invasion. Some look at him and give thanks for the victory and other’s… well, not so much.
In the path of his conquest, many indigenous and African people were killed. A good number of us in the United States count those massacred among our ancestors or we empathize with their plight. True, we are also descended from Europeans and have a new national identity as part of the U.S. But we’re still connected to the memory of the atrocities.
Felipe Fernandez-Armesto, a scholar and author of several books related to Columbus, including “1492: The Year the World Began,” said in the Associated Press recently, “Every hero is somebody else’s villain.” Part of me knows that my life is the legacy of Columbus. But that part is overwhelmed by sadness over the bloodshed caused by his “discovery” of the new world.
Even if my yoga teacher meant no harm–and it was just a coincidence that she happened to look right at me when she referred to Columbus being “open” to the “natives” — it still felt painful and humiliating to be in that situation. I was not getting any kind of bliss.
I imagined myself marching out in disgust, maybe slamming the door on my way out. But this was a yoga class. That would look extra crazy, as would cursing, spitting or any of the other things I felt like doing. Maybe this was just some sort of cosmic test for my ability to concentrate and continue with my practice.
After all, she wouldn’t bring up Christopher Columbus again would she? Yup, she did. Again and again. Among the most difficult moments, she said:
- to squat and reach our hands in an offering, like the native people to Columbus
- explore our poses like we were exploring the new land
- lift our knee up high like we were posing at Plymouth Rock
- do three versions of camel and the boat pose in honor of the Nina, the Pinta and Santa Maria
- when I did the full camel pose, “Good for you. Really pushing and honoring Christopher Columbus. People don’t celebrate him much these days. I wonder why…” (I eff you not)
Anyway, you get the picture. It went on and on… for the entire class. I would have been annoyed at seeing any analogy pimped this gratuitously but Columbus? The Indian killer, apologist for slavery, and ruthless opportunist? Really? In a yoga class? At the same studio with this quote in the women’s bathroom: “When the power of love overcomes the love of power, the world will know peace. – Jimi Hendrix”? Yoga class isn’t supposed to make one leave in serious need of a stiff drink.
5 Responses for "Dear Yoga Teacher, You Ruined Class Today by Dedicating it to Christopher Columbus"
great article. its so sad that the teacher is well intentioned but so lost. some ppl see no wrong in their ways, privilege and the effects of their supremacy and domination over of other ppl. i experienced an interesting conversation about capoeira the other day around a similar naivete. i’ll be sure not to teach a columbus day capoeira class today. or maybe i should teach one on behalf of the natives point of view.
-Imagine Columbus invading your homeland and raping and pillaging your land. Gauncho in the temple as hard as you can with all your might as if he is standing before you! Watch him drop to his knees as you fight to keep your freedom.
Ok first of all, even take columbus out of the picture, and this teacher clearly needs help. I mean a theme for a class is one thing but trite, beating-the-shit-out-of-the-metaphor, total disregard for the dharma is just depressing. She needs to go back to training.
But, obviously, way more of a problem here is her complete ignorance. I think it’s very unlikely this woman was doing this out of spite. I think she’s really just completely uneducated. Walking out would have made a statement, but she’s not necessarily smart enough to garner it. If you encounter her again (by accident, I would assume) the most compassionate thing you can do for this woman and a lot of people she’ll interact with is to try to help her understand why her actions were so offensive.
and tell her to go back to training.
Best status message of the day: Let us join together and celebrate Columbus Day by walking into someone’s house uninvited and telling them that you live there now.
Yeah, the class would have been horrible if she “dedicated” it as lamely to anything. Groundhog Day yoga would have been annoying too. The more I think about it though, the more I think that I should actually say something. I’m probably less angry and more capable of holding myself together now.
san diego yoga…
Yoga is an ancient form of spirituality that originated in India. It is deeply connected with the religious beliefs and practices of Hinduism and other Indian religions. Apart from providing spiritual solace and mental relaxation, yoga also helps in re…
Leave a reply